Skip to main content

Best Community Banks in America 2026

The top 50 community banks (FDIC-insured institutions with $100M to $1B in assets) ranked by combined Bank Health Score — Tier 1 capital ratio (35%), nonperforming loan ratio (30%), liquidity ratio (25%), and return on assets (10%). Top-ranked: Frederick Community Bank The (Paxton, Illinois) with a score of 100/100.

2,406 community banks analyzed. Data from FDIC Q2 2024.

Top 10 Community Banks by Health Score

#1A100

Frederick Community Bank The

Paxton, Illinois

$179M in assets · Tier 1 18.22% · NPL 0.00%

#2A100

Arrowhead Bank

Llano, Texas

$287M in assets · Tier 1 17.42% · NPL 0.00%

#3A100

Farmers&Merchants Stb Bloomf

Bloomfield, Nebraska

$205M in assets · Tier 1 21.33% · NPL 0.04%

#4A100

Alamosa State Bank

Alamosa, Colorado

$332M in assets · Tier 1 19.91% · NPL 0.00%

#5A100

Comerica B&T NA

Ann Arbor, Michigan

$116M in assets · Tier 1 198.62% · NPL 0.00%

#6A100

Commercial Banking Co

Valdosta, Georgia

$355M in assets · Tier 1 18.14% · NPL 0.04%

Full Top 50 Community Banks Ranked

#BankCityStateGradeScoreAssetsTier 1NPL
1Frederick Community Bank ThePaxtonIllinoisA100$179M18.22%0.00%
2Arrowhead BankLlanoTexasA100$287M17.42%0.00%
3Farmers&Merchants Stb BloomfBloomfieldNebraskaA100$205M21.33%0.04%
4Alamosa State BankAlamosaColoradoA100$332M19.91%0.00%
5Comerica B&T NAAnn ArborMichiganA100$116M198.62%0.00%
6Commercial Banking CoValdostaGeorgiaA100$355M18.14%0.04%
7Western BankArtesiaNew MexicoA100$341M14.90%0.00%
8Fnbt BankFort Walton BeacFloridaA100$597M24.62%0.01%
9Texas State BankSan AngeloTexasA100$402M19.41%0.00%
10Garden Plain State BankWichitaKansasA100$149M24.21%0.00%
11Bessemer Trust CoWoodbridgeNew JerseyA100$502M33.56%0.00%
12Summit BankOaklandCaliforniaA100$296M21.55%0.00%
13First Nb Northwest FloridaPanama CityFloridaA100$176M51.49%0.00%
14Edward Jones Trust CoSaint LouisMissouriA100$131M351.19%0.00%
15Titan Bank N AMineral WellsTexasA100$578M22.90%0.07%
16Grandview BankGrandviewTexasA100$642M16.21%0.02%
17Big Bend Banks N AMarfaTexasA100$156M38.37%0.00%
18Stifel Trust Co NASaint LouisMissouriA100$889M31.85%0.00%
19Fds BankMasonOhioA100$106M221.69%0.00%
20Applied BankWilmingtonDelawareA100$218M78.80%0.00%
21Nationwide Trust Co FSBColumbusOhioA100$152M95.00%0.00%
22Capital Bank&Trust CoIrvineCaliforniaA100$174M190.32%0.00%
23Alpine Capital BankNew YorkNew YorkA100$194M57.19%0.00%
24Sei Private Trust CoOaksPennsylvaniaA100$236M349.87%0.00%
25First Electronic BankSalt Lake CityUtahA100$429M62.24%0.00%
26First National Bank in OrdOrdNebraskaA100$150M21.22%0.00%
27First Nb of StantonStantonTexasA100$375M32.47%0.00%
28Amg National Trust BankBoulderColoradoA100$660M18.59%0.03%
29Trinity Bank N AFort WorthTexasA100$463M16.20%0.00%
30Bank of MontanaMissoulaMontanaA100$297M31.00%0.00%
31Stifel Trust Co Delaware NAGreenvilleDelawareA100$284M45.70%0.00%
32Adrian BankAdrianMissouriA100$178M20.60%0.02%
33Cibc National Trust CoAtlantaGeorgiaA100$354M216.31%0.00%
34Fidelity State Bank&Trust CoDodge CityKansasA99$198M128.61%0.14%
35Lake Region BankNew LondonMinnesotaA99$137M23.38%0.04%
36Franklin State Bank&Trust CoWinnsboroLouisianaA99$205M19.74%0.20%
37Columbus State BankColumbusTexasA99$152M32.00%0.00%
38Citizens Nb of QuitmanQuitmanGeorgiaA99$120M19.26%0.07%
39Northern State BankAshlandWisconsinA99$303M17.21%0.10%
40Durden Banking Co INCTwin CityGeorgiaA99$279M22.69%0.21%
41Citizens Bank of AmericusAmericusGeorgiaA99$426M15.84%0.09%
42Community 1st Bank Las VegasLas VegasNew MexicoA99$238M17.76%0.01%
43First Kansas BankHoisingtonKansasA99$264M18.65%0.00%
44Centinel Bank of TaosTaosNew MexicoA99$405M23.98%0.03%
45First Nb of WaynesboroWaynesboroGeorgiaA99$208M30.95%0.21%
46Bank of the SouthwestRoswellNew MexicoA99$178M16.05%0.13%
47Community Bank of RaymoreRaymoreMissouriA99$351M19.94%0.12%
48Nekoosa Port Edwards StbNekoosaWisconsinA99$258M27.25%0.00%
49First Nb of DublinDublinTexasA99$128M15.88%0.10%
50Kentucky Farmers Bank CorpCatlettsburgKentuckyA99$278M27.28%0.08%

How we rank community banks

Every FDIC-insured community bank ($100M-$1B in assets) gets a Bank Health Score (0-100) calculated from four FDIC Call Report metrics:

  • Tier 1 capital ratio (35% weight) — core equity vs risk-weighted assets. 8%+ is "well-capitalized" by federal standards.
  • Nonperforming loan ratio (30%) — loans 90+ days past due as a share of total loans. Lower is better; below 1% is strong.
  • Liquidity ratio (25%) — cash and liquid assets vs short-term obligations. Higher is better.
  • Return on assets (10%) — annual net income vs total assets. ROA above 1% is considered strong; negative ROA means the bank is losing money.

All data sourced from quarterly FDIC Call Reports — the same regulatory filings used by federal bank examiners.

Community Bank Health Scores are calculated from FDIC Call Report data including Tier 1 capital ratios, nonperforming loan ratios, liquidity ratios, and return on assets.

Frequently Asked Questions

The "best" community bank depends on your needs — savings rates, branch access, fees, and digital services all matter. From a pure financial-health perspective, the banks ranked above have the strongest combined scores on Tier 1 capital, loan quality, liquidity, and profitability among institutions with $100M-$1B in assets. All are FDIC-insured up to $250,000 per depositor per ownership category.

They serve different niches. Credit unions are member-owned non-profits — typically lower fees and slightly better savings rates, but smaller branch networks and limited business banking. Community banks ($100M-$1B in assets) are for-profit but locally rooted — broader product range, business-oriented, more branches in their geographic area. Both are insured (FDIC for banks, NCUA for credit unions, both up to $250K).

There's no single "top 5" — it depends on whether you prioritize national reach (Chase, BofA, Wells Fargo dominate locations), high savings rates (online banks like Marcus, Ally, Synchrony), or local relationships (community banks). The top community banks by financial health are listed above. For high-yield savings, online-only banks routinely beat community banks.

There is no specific "$3,000 rule." This phrase typically refers to the IRS reporting threshold for cash transactions — banks must file Currency Transaction Reports (CTRs) for cash deposits or withdrawals over $10,000, and Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) for unusual patterns at lower amounts. Some sources use $3,000 to discuss multiple smaller transactions that aggregate to a reportable amount (called "structuring," which is illegal). Routine deposits under $10,000 are not flagged.

Most community banks are well-capitalized and FDIC-insured up to $250K per depositor per ownership category. Community banks tend to have stickier customer relationships and conservative loan books — but they're also more concentrated geographically, so a regional downturn can hit them harder than a megabank. Check the Bank Health Score (above) for any specific bank: an A or B grade signals strong capital and clean loan books.

There's no single legal definition, but the FDIC considers community banks as institutions focused on traditional lending and deposit gathering within a specific geography. By asset size, the FDIC uses a $10B-$15B threshold for community-bank research, but in common usage "community bank" usually means $100M-$1B in assets — large enough to offer full services, small enough to be locally rooted. The list above uses the $100M-$1B definition.

Community banks: $100M-$1B in assets, single state or metro area, local lending focus. Regional banks: $1B-$10B+ in assets, multi-state footprint, broader product mix including business banking and wealth management. Mid-size banks ($1B-$10B) are the bridge. Both can be FDIC-insured.

Sources: FDIC BankFind API
Last updated:

Bank Health Scores are computed from quarterly FDIC Call Report data. Tier 1 capital ratio (35%), nonperforming loan ratio (30%), liquidity ratio (25%), and return on assets (10%).